close
    1. Home
      2. ›
    2. Society & Culture
      3. ›
    3. Religion & Spirituality
      4. ›
    4. Do you think Judas had a choice in what he did?
    Do you think Judas had a choice in what he did?

    Answer this
    +6  Views: 672 Answers: 16 Posted: 14 years ago
    Comment this question

      16 Answers

      I agree with the consensus here, we all have free will, but truth be known, we can't surprise God.
      14 years ago. Rating: 9
      Comment this answer

        of course we all have freewill although he might have been predestined he still had a choice..

        14 years ago. Rating: 6
        Comment this answer

          Betrayal was always a human weakness, even before Christ.
          14 years ago. Rating: 6
          Comment this answer

            All of us have choices, some make bad ones, and some make good ones.
            14 years ago. Rating: 5
            Comment this answer

              you bring up a good point, but yes I think Judas had a choice, maybe God just wanted to put him to the test.
              14 years ago. Rating: 5
              Comment this answer

                bestway

                God did not put him to the test.
                Satan put him to the test.
                Satan saw the fatal flaw in his character, money.
                commented 14 years ago
                …"someone to lead the lamb to slaughter.” Pilot
                14 years ago. Rating: 4
                Comment this answer

                  robertgrist

                  “Pilot” aka Dangerous, child of Persephone
                  commented 14 years ago
                  I THINK ONE OF THE DECIPILES WAS GOING TO BETRAY HIM IF NOT JUDAS ANOTHER.WHO IS TO SAY JUDAS WAS THE FIRST APPROACHED?
                  14 years ago. Rating: 4
                  Comment this answer

                    I think he had a choice,but he choose to betray someone that he was supposed to be close to,although Jesus was prepared because he knew Judas had a false love for him,it was all a facade,he turned his back on Jesus,this exists today,people just out to hurt others,especially if there is a pay off involved,that to me is just sad....the ultimate betrayal, when you cant trust those closest to you.
                    14 years ago. Rating: 4
                    Comment this answer

                      god can see ahead down the road. He could see that Judas was going to betray Christ, so it's a mute point.
                      14 years ago. Rating: 3
                      Comment this answer

                        Of course he did, b/c God gave us all free will. Judas didn't expect it to end up the way it did; and that's why he committed suicide. He was going to betray Christ, just for the money.
                        It was a bribe.
                        14 years ago. Rating: 3
                        Comment this answer

                          Jesus knew He would betray Him all along, that's why He chose him, He had to die.
                          14 years ago. Rating: 3
                          Comment this answer

                            he served justice on himself and for all eternity does anyone know of a person named Judas today
                            14 years ago. Rating: 3
                            Comment this answer

                              Was He part of the plan
                              14 years ago. Rating: 3
                              Comment this answer

                                Judas did have free will what is interesting 30 pieces of silver is the price for a healthy male slave he was greedy he asked what will you pay me for you to take you him ? then all the illegal trials Judas said I have betrayed an innocent man then the high priest said whats that to us this is on your own head then he throw money at them and left and hanged him self
                                14 years ago. Rating: 1
                                Comment this answer

                                  Yes. He approved of the video: http://youtu.be/wagn8Wrmzuc

                                  13 years ago. Rating: 0
                                  Comment this answer

                                    We all have choices.

                                    13 years ago. Rating: 0
                                    Comment this answer



                                      Did this answer your question? If not, then ask a new question.
                                      Related Questions In This Category
                                      Which verses in the Qur’an mention the killing of disbelievers, and what is the context of these verses?
                                      Answers: 0 | Views: 21 | Rating: 0 | Posted: 5 days ago

                                      Top contributors in Religion & Spirituality category

                                       
                                      Benthere
                                      Answers: 29 / Questions: 0
                                      Karma: 37150
                                       
                                      jhharlan
                                      Answers: 366 / Questions: 0
                                      Karma: 31325
                                       
                                      Colleen
                                      Answers: 621 / Questions: 4
                                      Karma: 27960
                                       
                                      ROMOS
                                      Answers: 361 / Questions: 0
                                      Karma: 27160
                                      > Top contributors chart

                                      Unanswered Questions

                                      The Longines Heritage Military Watch, Another Great Throwback Design
                                      Answers: 0 Views: 5 Rating: 0
                                      33winuk1
                                      Answers: 0 Views: 4 Rating: 0
                                      EV88 Jqkio
                                      Answers: 0 Views: 24 Rating: 0
                                      365ggprocom
                                      Answers: 0 Views: 29 Rating: 0
                                      dangnhap5679com
                                      Answers: 0 Views: 16 Rating: 0
                                      88vvbroker
                                      Answers: 0 Views: 22 Rating: 0
                                      Nhà Đài Km88
                                      Answers: 0 Views: 15 Rating: 0
                                      WinClash
                                      Answers: 0 Views: 15 Rating: 0
                                      > More questions...
                                      496948
                                      questions
                                      732499
                                      answers
                                      833147
                                      users