close
    Schapelle Corby. Guilty or innocent?

    Now that Schapelle is back in the news the question arrises again.I would not have liked to be on that jury.To this day I don't think she was 100% guilty.Nor do I think she was 100% innocent.A hard decision.I do think the sentence was harsh.20 Years is a long time.The one thing that sways me toward a guilty verdict is the boogie board they found the dope in.Why carry one to Bali when you could buy one there for 5 Bucks?

    +3  Views: 1024 Answers: 3 Posted: 11 years ago

    3 Answers

    It was only "Mary Jane" but if you do it there they're going to put you away for a long time.


    She's done her time, hope she gets home safely.


    KOTF

    Colleen

    Moderator
    She's not free yet.......

    Foreign Minister Bob Carr has denied claims that a deal has been struck to bring Schapelle Corby home early in return for freeing young Indonesian people smugglers held in Australian jails.

    Corby will be free much sooner than expected after Indonesian president Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono approved a five-year cut to her original 20-year sentence.

    Combined with maximum time off for good behaviour, Corby would be released in mid-2015, but she could be released earlier based on the recommendation of justice department officials.

    Indonesia's minister for the state secretriat, Sudi Silalahi, said Mr Yudhoyono cut Corby's prison term on humanitarian grounds.

    But he also described the decision is also part of a reciprocal arrangement with Australia, which has already returned some young Indonesians accused of crewing asylum seeker boats.

    "It's not just a promise. Many have been followed through and they've already returned," he said.

    Indonesia's law and human rights minister, Amir Syamsudin, said the cut to Corby's prison term should encourage Australia to release more young Indonesians held on people smuggling charges.

    Earlier this month the Federal Government announced a review of more than 20 cases of Indonesian people smugglers who were convicted as adults but who may be children.

    Three young Indonesian men were released from a West Australian prison last week, after there was sufficient doubt that they were under 18 years of age when they were caught.

    The Attorney-General's Department is continuing to review a further 22 cases.

    But Senator Carr has denied any deal has been done.

    "The decision about minors in Australian jails was made because of the merits of the case," he said.

    "It was a very strong case made by Indonesian government people, most recently when the foreign minister of Indonesia met me in March.

    "But the two things aren't linked."

    Senator Carr could not say when Corby would be released.

    "Any argument about parole would be something for Ms Corby's legal representatives to lodge, an earlier release would depend on remissions," he said.

    "The Australian Government has consistently supported Ms Corby's application for clemency on humanitarian grounds."

    A letter from Mr Yudhoyono has been delivered to Denpasar court confirming the five-year sentence cut, but Corby has yet to see the letter because it must first be sent to the local prosecutor.

    Corby, from the Gold Coast, was arrested at Bali's international airport in October 2004 attempting to import more than four kilograms of marijuana in her boogie board bag.

    In a case that captivated public attention in Australia, she claimed she did not own the drugs and had been set up.

    But she was sentenced to 20 years in prison and lost all of her appeals.

    She has been held at Bali's Kerobokan prison ever since.

    After Corby asked Indonesia's president for clemency in 2010, a supreme court judge advised him to grant a five-year sentence cut.
    Tommyh

    Me too KOTF.8 Years is plenty.
    Tommyh

    Thanks Colleen for the history.The family is hoping for a release as early as July but even with the reductions she has been granted she still has 5 years to serve.
    Tommyh

    The troube with Bali is it's too bloody close to Australia.There have been many harsh sentences handed to Australians for drug offences over the years.Even hangings!
    ROMOS

    I knew all this before I answered Colleen, the girls done her time in my opinion!

    "" I made up my mind when I read this book.Schapelle and her dad were partners in crime.I say guilty as charged.She has had more than enough punishment, let this broken woman come home.

    Tom, she has been back and forth a few times, i'm afraid, i think she is guilty as sin. The way things are going in Bali with methanol vodka drinks, and drugs only a 'mug' would go there.

    Tommyh

    I have heard thru the Gold Coast grapevine that her parents fish & chip shop is "Drug Central".As I have said,she is not all that innocent & why would you take a boogy board to bali? You could buy one there for next to nothing.


    Top contributors in News & Events category

     
    jhharlan
    Answers: 22 / Questions: 0
    Karma: 2685
     
    ROMOS
    Answers: 37 / Questions: 0
    Karma: 2565
     
    Colleen
    Answers: 68 / Questions: 1
    Karma: 2310
     
    Benthere
    Answers: 2 / Questions: 1
    Karma: 2115
    > Top contributors chart

    Unanswered Questions

    Gi8
    Answers: 0 Views: 10 Rating: 0
    thabetaicom
    Answers: 0 Views: 5 Rating: 0
    88betcuoc
    Answers: 0 Views: 10 Rating: 0
    88betcuoc
    Answers: 0 Views: 9 Rating: 0
    88betcuoc
    Answers: 0 Views: 9 Rating: 0
    > More questions...
    452415
    questions
    719768
    answers
    754671
    users