Bob/PKB
Ashley is a 15 yr old border collie mix. She's alert, active, affectionate, and has a lesion on her skin the groomer diagnosed as cancer. My son, her "master", is waffling about getting her to a vet because she is "105".
Darrell, our "toothless" dog, 10, is also alert, active, and lovable. He is fed mushy food.
And Bruce, 6 year old American Bulldog, has legs that "pop" in and out. He is busy and feisty, too.
My son talks about putting all 3 down (via bullets to their heads after a day to remember, in dog world) with the idea he should adopt animals from shelters and give them good lives.
I don't have a problem with him wanting to "save" animals, but destroying the loyal and loving pets we have now is abhorrent to me. He is their caregiver, as I have my other son's dog with me; he doesn't get along with our dogs and my yard is very, very small. He loves the dogs we have, so I am having trouble understanding the logic.
What are your thoughts about this scenario??? (Three question marks for three dogs)
Why do you call your son the dogs master? Animals need friends, not masters.
Tell your son to grow up. Sorry but he has no compassion for these animals. He should not have any. To say "bullet in the head" is showing he sees them merely as animals with no feeling or Soul. He should not have pets no matter how much you think he loves them. He is balking at the responsibility of taking care of an aged being. Throw it away and get something younger and new. I hope you have no plans of him looking after you in your elderly years......
The one in question here has the mis-notion he has been abused and neglected. It has come to the point where I literally balk at going to my mom's because he harasses me from the moment I step across the threshold.
I plan on taking the dog to the vet if he has not done so by the end of this week (today is Thursday). I know just when I can take and return her without him knowing.
My condo yard is small and my son's dog is with me. When my son is able to take his dog, I will go get at least one of the dogs from my mom's (she wants to keep them all and keep them well).
21 Answers
pythonlover
I would think your dogs deserve more than a bullet to their heads, what a way to end their lives.If your son feels the need to kill them, a vet can do this more humanely.
| 11 years ago. Rating: 18 | |
Tommyh
Putting down a good dog after 15 years is very difficult.I had that experience last year.(RIP Pippa after 17 years). If the dog is comfortable & happy try to convince your son to let him be,at least for the time being. I was planning to euthanise my dog myself & my wife talked me out of it.I'm glad she did.I took her to the vet to do it.It was gentle & calm but I was still a blubbering mess when I carried her out to the truck. Putting down all 3 dogs to go save others seems a bit extreme.Try to talk him out of it. Good luck with it Bob.Tommy
| 11 years ago. Rating: 18 | |
I plan on taking the dogs for "physicals" and getting the opinion of a professional.
jhharlan
Oh, Bob. I wouldn't want to be in your shoes. Putting a dog down is such a major decision I don't think should be made. How is the dog's quality of life? That is the determining factor............
| 11 years ago. Rating: 17 | |
If it isn't one of them going bonkers, it's another one.
FISH-O
I would take the dog to the vet... many skin lesions and bumps are not cancer. 'Many' as in most.
I once cured an incurable dog with essential fatty acids, kelp, glucosomine, probiotics and a change of kibble... apparently she had cancer as well. What she actually had was allergies.
15 years for a Border Collie is quite amazing.
If you are taking care of the dogs then you know the dogs.
In my eyes a bullet is violent. I have always done my very best to give my dogs a great life and when it's time, I leave it up to them to tell me when enough is enough. And ... truly, they do.
This always is a tough time Bobette. We usually out live our pets. Best wishes, Fishie.
| 11 years ago. Rating: 16 | |
Thursday I have to go to the city my mom lives in for a doc appt. so I will get Ashley afterwards and take her to the vet.
My son is such an enigma with the dogs. He got an old couch and set it up in a place in the yard where Darrell could stretch out on it (we had one behind the garage when we lived in the country and Darrell loved it). He blends the dry food to a powder, soaks it and mixes it with canned food for all the dogs. He puts an electric heater outside in a little cove by the house for them in the winter and has a fan going in the garage for them during the summer. He plays with and exercises all of them; it is obvious he loves them.
Like you said, they will tell us when they are tired. They aren't tired yet.
Thanks for your helpful thoughts, Fishie.
(I hear you had a birthday over the weekend and I didn't get to wish you a happy one; so I will wish you a coming year filled with joy, good health, success, and love)
Dardaigh
Ann
I think you already know what to do. God bless your heart, The dogs dont seem to have a major problem it would be very unfair to put them to death, the way your son wants to do it. I shudder to think about it.
I hope Ashley can get treatment and the Vet will know, what is best. I was told, never to ask a vet if you schould put your "friend" down. They dont like to make that decision, its up to you. Let me know when you take her to the Vet.
| 11 years ago. Rating: 14 | |
Two vet had told us to put her down because of her behaviors. Even after that we couldn’t do it. Not an easy thing to do!
Part of me thinks that he doesn't want to take "old" stuff into his marriage (which has no official date, as far as I know). The fiancee would like a dog, and I am sure she would like a puppy for the two of them to have as "their" dog. Makes sense, but my kid is way off on his logic. My mom says she will keep all three of the dogs. When my middle son can take his dog, I will take at least one of the dogs. What a mess.
I will keep you updated on what goes on at the vet's and thank you for you care and concern.
clu
I would let a vet see dog #1 It may just be a treatable tumor. All the dogs seem to be coping with their problems. Does your son just not want to spend any money on them? They are loyal pets and if they seem happy--Let them live. However if they are in pain that is different! How could he shoot his pet unless absolutely necessary???
| 11 years ago. Rating: 14 | |
daren1
So sorry to hear Bobbby I'm sure you loved this little guy, best just to do the humane thing a let em go gently why not consider a new puppy I'm sure it will help to ease the pain..
| 11 years ago. Rating: 13 | |
Ducky
To shoot your own pet, seems rather heartless to me, so like you Bob, I don't get it either. I have known people though, who were hunters, lived out in the country, and really believed that it was a simple solution to "getting rid of" a pet, no matter the reason. I also know that one of those men regretted his actions forever. He said, many years later, that it was the wrong thing to do and he has always felt terrible about it.
| 11 years ago. Rating: 11 | |
lindilou
In my world only a "bad" dog gets the bullet!! I'm talking about the kind of dog who kills 200 chickens for the thrill...or the one that attacks the neighbors' loved one...THAT dog gets the bullet. But a good dog that is in need of euthanasia ought be put to sleep at the vet. It does not sound to me that any of these dogs are in jeopardy or that any of them is a "bad" sort of dog? It sounds contradictory to kill these dogs just to replace them with others?? I don't get it either Bob?
| 11 years ago. Rating: 11 | |
This is all too personal. My dogs and cats have been more steadfast than most people I know.
doolittle
Doolittle is soooo confused. Your son already has 3 adopted 'kids'- dogs...Now that they have issues that don't seem to be interfering with their lives or happiness he wants to put them down and help other dogs?????? Does he think he will get puppies or dogs at the p ound that are healthy and have no, or will not get "issues"???? This is bizarre logic. Take the dog with the tumor to the vet. If your son is 'dead' set on putting down these dogs couldn't giving them away be an option too?? ....and before I agreed to new pound puppies He needs to figure out what he will do if the puppies are or do get sick- or have non-life threatening/ non-quality of life threatening disabilities??
| 11 years ago. Rating: 11 | |
One summer I was teaching and when I opened the door for recess, Darrell was there, about 4 months old and covered with tics. My middle son maneuvered him into a "caged" area; after school, we wrapped him in newsprint and took him to my folks' (fenced yard). My brother-in-law took him to the vet for the tics, and we took him home to be with Sophie, Ashley, and Patch. My eldest named him Darrell, which fits him perfectly for some reason.
Bruce was supposed to be "high quality" and my friend's daughter was trying to sell him to get money for dope. I took him so he wouldn't go to some joker who would abuse him, like so many do with pit bulls (chopping off their ears and tails and making them fight each other).
Not long ago there were 14 dogs at my mom's (my four, my eldest had two and one of them had 8 puppies). Two of the puppies contracted parvo and my mom said to take them to the vet and get them treated. I won't tell you how much it cost, but they both survived.
I don't know how my son thinks his plan makes sense....
Fortunately, my middle son, the one on the jail tour of 2012, wants to take care of me when I'm too decrepit to take care of myself. In spite of the tour, he's the compassionate one. I think I'll be safe, even if my jewelry isn't.
lambshank
We don't shoot sick people, nor would I ever consider this for any animal, if they are in pain and have no quality of life let a vet do it humanely, I can't understand anyone looking at a much loved pet and putting a bullet in it, whilst entertaining the idea of replacement like you would another kitchen appliance, I may sound harsh, but I do not understand his way of thinking at all
| 11 years ago. Rating: 11 | |
facebook
Sorry Bob/PKB!! My sympathy but if the dogs are suffuring than they should be put to sleep.
| 11 years ago. Rating: 11 | |
Ashley should go to the vet before any decision is made by a layman.
melandrupert
Oh Bob what can i say first of all as Colleen had said you must take this dog to get it probley diagnosed then if that is the case and its not in pain then let it live until it needs to put to sleep I think your Son is your problem where is is head he says he loves animals and I agree that all animals should come from rescue centres but to put bulits in a dogs head is sick I am sorry that this is your son but I see it how it is and I will not back down from my feelings all animals wether strays aggresive desearve dignity and humane killings not a bulit in the head we live in the 21st century not 18th century where one had nothing but BULLITS to shoot animals I think you should have have a good talk to your Son on this subject and I reall hope your Dog does not have cancer but if that is the case it sounds to me that your family have given the dog a good life sorry for getting a bit high-rate but you should know what I am like where animals are concern thanks Bob
| 11 years ago. Rating: 10 | |
I don't know exactly what his problem is, but he exacerbates it being a pot head, and I am about done with his theatrics and domineering attitude. I talked with his dad this morning and he is as much at a loss and flabbergasted as I.
mallybud
hector5559
itsmee
Pets have this special place in their life with us. They can’t talk and really tell us. We can only guess. When someone has put years of love into the life of a pet, they will make this most difficult decision. Your son’s idea would not be the right one for me. Maybe your words will change him as this way is not your idea either. I wish the best for you both.
| 11 years ago. Rating: 9 | |
KRIFF
mycatsmom
Do all the dogs live with you ? And did you buy them ,and pay their vet bills and their food, etc ? If so, than, you, Phyllis will / should have the final say about them.
I'm suprised any dog is 15 ! Dogs live a lot longer than they used to. Maybe that's why they're getting more diseases......like diabetes and cancer.
The " bullets to the head " makes me feel sick. Why not keep them alive , as long as they're not suffering. Then, if they are suffering, take them to the vet for a humane euthanasia.
| 11 years ago. Rating: 8 | |
LOG IN
bustieone
Truth be known, a bullet is a humane was to euthanize, if done properly. I have a best friend who is a successful veterinarian, and he made this statement to me one day, defending a man who had put his own dog down. He obviously doesn't urge his clients to do this, as it is not legal to discharge a weapon in most areas, and humane organizations may not know all the facts and wish to prosecute an owner for cruelty. However, I agree that your son should have a responsibility to the pets currently within his responsibility, and do not take the word of a groomer, the dog could indeed have a tumor, but it may be benign! Good luck
| 11 years ago. Rating: 4 | |
Currently, he is one of the most irresponsible, disrespectful, unpleasant beings I know, and that includes Umbriel.
But thank you for your answer.
